HR Outsourcing: Advantages & Disadvantages

Outsourcing advantages & disadvantages

Depending on your company size and structure, one single job role might be juggling everything from onboarding employees to performance management to inspiring company culture to managing organisational structure and change. It’s often a little unrealistic to expect one person to have all the expertise (and calendar space) to fulfil all of these requirements.

That’s why so many companies turn to HR outsourcing or HR consultants.

What is HR outsourcing?

HR outsourcing involves a company engaging third party consultants or a HR agency to carry out certain duties. Often, the company is experiencing transition as a result of growth, leadership change or development, but this is certainly not always the case.

‍Outsourced HR provides additional resources to a company, allowing them to continue with the day to day functioning of the business, without interruption as a result of understaffing or change.

It’s quite typical for the Outsourced HR team to adopt the more strategic role of a project, but again, this is not always necessarily the case. What you’d be introducing is options and support, but many companies still sit on the fence, delaying the decision as to whether outsourcing the HR function would be beneficial. If you have concerns, it might be useful to explore common misconceptions about outsourced HR.

If this sounds like you or your company, keep reading.

Advantages of HR outsourcing

HR outsourcing offers significant benefits to organisations, primarily through substantial cost savings by eliminating the need for a full-time, in-house HR team. It provides access to specialised expertise and ensures compliance with labour laws, minimizing legal risks. Some more advantages of HR outsourcing includes:

1. Cost Efficiency: Significant reduction in HR-related overhead costs.
2. Compliance and Legal Protection: Ensures adherence to labour laws, reducing the risk of legal issues and fines.
3. Strategic Focus: Allows company leadership to concentrate on strategic initiatives rather than administrative HR tasks.
4. Access to Talent: Better recruitment outcomes due to professional handling and broader reach.
5. Operational Flexibility: Ability to quickly adapt to changing business needs without the constraints of managing HR staff.
6. Enhanced Employee Experience: Improved HR services lead to higher employee satisfaction and retention.
7. Data-Driven Decisions: Access to advanced analytics and reporting tools for informed decision-making.
8. Quality Training Programs: Access to superior training resources to keep employees skilled and competitive.
9. Advanced HR Technology: Utilization of the latest HR tech without the need for direct investment.
10. Risk Mitigation: Reduced exposure to HR-related risks and improved handling of sensitive employee issues.

HR outsourcing benefits

The biggest practical advantage to outsourcing HR functions is that it will fulfil a need. Typically, businesses look for a HR partner or Outsourced HR team because they cannot facilitate the function in house any more. This could be for some of the following reasons:

• The responsibility of HR is being fulfilled by an executive or leader who also has other demands. Often, this is the CFO or Finance Director who is becoming overloaded.
• There is an existing HR manager or team in place but the company is transitioning, experiencing change or conflict which the in-house team needs resourcing and expert support with.
• The company is looking to implement a special initiative or project. Perhaps this is coaching, organisational design or introducing an improved employee value proposition that the in house team does not have experience with.

Without outsourcing HR, the company would not be able to move forward efficiently within these scenarios. It can be particularly prudent to seek expert consultation if you are dealing with a scenario as time-sensitive and open to risk as workplace investigations and disputes.

When the HR function flails or lags, internal morale can slump. Employees' engagement can suffer because their confidence that the company they work for is equipped, can support them and cares about them drops.  

HumanX HR helps you diagnose and manage any scenario with an intelligent, human-first approach, but we also open your team up to expansion and education.

Our experts have decades of experience in dynamic, transitional HR scenarios. They bring thought-leadership, problem solving and fresh ideas. Working closely with your leaders, in-house HR teams and collaborating throughout the company, one of the biggest pros of working with HumanX as your Outsourced HR partner is that we help you grow. You get access to senior, executive level coaching, decision making and insights, without agenda and without delay.

Strategic Investment

Another pro of outsourcing HR that cannot be overlooked is that you can access the skill, knowledge and consultation of HR experts, without the financial commitment of taking another person in house.

Research indicates that it can cost almost $35000 to find and recruit a senior member of staff. The average salary for a human resources manager in Australia also ranges from $115,000 to $135,000. That number is also on the rise as a result of a shortage of qualified candidates making it their market.

The advantages to outsourcing HR is that you do not have this sunken cost of recruitment which you will have to pay out before you get any return. Not to mention the time that recruitment can take, especially to fulfil a role as sensitive and nuanced as in-house HR.

Outsourcing HR functions to an agency will give you immediate access and support. You also have no commitment to the agency once a project is over. This means that you have retained the upfront capital of recruitment, as well as avoided an ongoing salary unnecessarily.

When you partner with HumanX HR, you get access to our entire team. This means that you get to have an entire outsourced HR department with varied skills, specialisms and availability which would be almost impossible to find in one person.

Risk Management

It’s often advised, as well as advantageous to outsource HR or introduce external experts in certain situations. We have mentioned some of them already in this article, but consider any situation where your company might be open to a dispute or fine, primarily, workplace investigations or workplace health and safety.

In these situations, external teams demonstrate impartiality and promote procedural fairness. These are highly specialised and sensitive scenarios in which your in-house team may not have adequate knowledge or any experience. External expertise can help to mitigate the risk.

On a project-basis, a pro of outsourcing HR to run a health check or HR audit can give you fresh eyes, help you identify gaps that may be leaving your company open to risk. This could be within your HR policies, leadership practices and more.

Cons of outsourcing HR

Outsourcing HR functions offers various benefits, but it also presents challenges that can impact the business. Key drawbacks include reduced control over HR processes, confidentiality concerns, and potential cultural mismatches. Companies may face issues such as dependency on external vendors, variable service quality, and hidden costs. Additionally, communication barriers and standardization limitations can complicate the transition. Understanding these cons is essential for organizations to make informed decisions about HR outsourcing.

1. Loss of Control: Reduced direct oversight and control over HR functions and processes.
2. Confidentiality Concerns: Potential risks related to data security and confidentiality of sensitive employee information.
3. Cultural Mismatch: External HR providers may not fully understand or integrate with the company’s culture and values.
4. Service Quality Issues: Variable quality of service depending on the third-party provider’s performance and expertise.
5. Employee Morale: Employees might feel disconnected or less valued due to the impersonal nature of outsourced HR services.
6. Dependency on Vendor: Increased reliance on an external provider can create vulnerability if the provider fails to deliver or goes out of business.
7. Hidden Costs: Potential for unforeseen expenses and additional fees beyond the initial contract.
8. Communication Challenges: Possible difficulties in communication and coordination between the company and the outsourced HR provider.
9. Standardization Limitations: Off-the-shelf HR solutions may not be tailored to the specific needs of the company, leading to less effective HR management.
10. Transition and Implementation Issues: Challenges and disruptions during the transition period from in-house to outsourced HR services.

HumanX HR, based in Sydney, assists national and multinational companies with human capital and business development. If you have concerns about HR outsourcing, it may stem from issues like poor communication, lack of transparency, or cultural disconnects within your organisation. These are challenges we can address as your outsourced HR partners. At HumanX HR, we prioritise people, recognising them as your greatest asset, while also focusing on the broader business context. Contact us to learn more about the benefits of HR outsourcing with HumanX HR and discover how our unique, people-first approach can support your business.

‍